The listings featured on this site are from companies from which this site receives compensation. This influences where, how and in what order such listings appear on this site.
Adv Disclosure
We aim to provide valuable content and useful comparison features to our visitors through our free online resource. It's important to note that we receive advertising compensation from companies featured on our site, which influences the positioning and order in which brands (and/or their products) are displayed, as well as the assigned score. Please be aware that the inclusion of company listings on this page doesn't imply endorsement. We don't feature all providers available in the market. Any information presented on this page, including pricing, is subject to change without notice. We want to emphasize that we disclaim all representations and warranties concerning the accuracy of the information provided on this site, unless otherwise explicitly stated in our Terms of Use
Close
default
Best Home Warranty Companies in Ohio 2025
Coverage Beyond Your Homeowners Insurance
Home insurance covers major events, while home warranties handle the inevitable repairs caused by wear and tear. Compare home warranty
companies to get the coverage your appliances and systems need.
default
Updated June 2025
Best Home Warranty Companies in Ohio in 2025
Get Peace of Mind at a Low Cost
Shield your wallet from unexpected repair costs. Compare home warranty companies to find the one that suits you best.
default
Updated June 2025
Best Home Warranty Companies 2025
Get Peace of Mind at a Low Cost
default
Updated June 2025

Our Top Choice

default
default
9.9
View Plans

Our Top Choice

default
default
9.1
View Plans

Our Top Choice

default
default
8.3
View Plans
1
Editor's Choice
default
logo image
9.9
info icon
Exceptional
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
9.6
9.9
info icon
Exceptional
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
9.6
default
Beat the Heat Sale!
  • Get $75 off + 1 month FREE
  • 24/7 call centers available
  • Covered over 2 million homes
  • Thousands of 5-star customer ratings
8482371489
View Plans
2
logo image
9.1
info icon
Outstanding
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.0
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.4
9.1
info icon
Outstanding
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.0
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.4
Join 2M+ members
  • 50% OFF Select Plans
  • Covers all appliances & systems
  • 30-day workmanship guarantee
  • 24/7 claims service
3
logo image
8.3
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
8.2
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
8.6
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.0
8.3
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
8.2
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
8.6
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.0
Get 2 months free
  • Great coverage for homeowners
  • Extensive coverage plans
  • Award-winning service
8772696437
4
logo image
8.0
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.3
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
7.5
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
7.4
8.0
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.3
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
7.5
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
7.4
Trusted for over 25 years
  • $150 OFF + 1 month free
  • 24/7 online claims available
  • Covers appliances & systems
5
logo image
8.2
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
8.4
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
7.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.4
8.2
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
8.4
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
7.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.4
25,000+ contractors nationwide
  • $75 OFF + 1 month FREE
  • 24/7 customer support
  • No age limit on covered items
6
logo image
8.7
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.7
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
8.3
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.6
8.7
info icon
Very Good
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.7
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
8.3
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
8.6
Coverage starting at $1/day
  • Get $200 OFF + 2 free months
  • Free roof leak protection
  • Thousands of vetted technicians
8339989286
Our #1 Pick For Home Warranty Services
logo image
9.9
info icon
Exceptional
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
9.6
9.9
info icon
Exceptional
Scores are calculated based on:
Brand Performance
Based on data insights
default
9.9
Customer Engagement
Based on click-share
default
9.9
Products & Offerings
Based on our
editorial analysis
default
9.6
  • 15,000+ local technicians
  • Handled 4M+ service requests
  • Straightforward service fee
  • Customizable packages
8482371489
2,409,735
people compared home warranty companies with
default
How We Score
Our Top 3 Picks
squareLogoUrl
American Home Shield
Read Review

What Is a Home Warranty and Why Might You Need One?

A home warranty is a service contract that covers the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances due to normal wear and tear. Unlike homeowners insurance, which covers damage from events like fires or storms, a home warranty focuses on the functionality of systems like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, as well as appliances such as refrigerators and ovens. By paying a monthly or annual premium, homeowners can mitigate unexpected repair costs, ensuring peace of mind and financial predictability.

Understanding Home Warranty Coverage

What Does a Home Warranty Typically Cover?

  • Home Systems: HVAC, electrical, plumbing, water heaters, and ductwork
  • Appliances: Refrigerators, ovens, dishwashers, washers, dryers, and built-in microwaves
  • Optional Add-Ons: Swimming pools, septic systems, well pumps, additional refrigerators, or stand-alone freezers

Coverage varies by provider, so always review contract details to understand coverage limitations and exclusions.

Do I Need a Home Warranty If I Have Home Insurance?

Yes, because they serve different purposes and complement each other. Home insurance covers structural damage or losses caused by events like fires, theft, storms, or vandalism. In contrast, a home warranty focuses on everyday appliance breakdowns or failures of essential systems like HVAC, plumbing, or electrical wiring due to normal wear and tear.

By combining both, homeowners benefit from a more comprehensive protection plan. Insurance guards your property from disasters, while a home warranty helps you avoid out-of-pocket repair bills from regular system and appliance malfunctions.

Home Warranty vs. Homeowners Insurance

A home warranty provides financial coverage for repairs or replacements of key appliances and systems due to regular usage over time. It typically includes things like central air conditioning, water heaters, refrigerators, and washers.

Homeowners insurance, on the other hand, protects the physical structure of your home and its contents from unforeseen hazards like fire, theft, windstorms, or liability claims. It's often required by mortgage lenders and comes with higher premiums than a home warranty.

While a home warranty is optional, it acts as a helpful complement to homeowners' insurance, ensuring coverage for common breakdowns not caused by disasters. Together, they provide a safety net for both catastrophic events and routine failures.

Financial Considerations

Home warranty plans generally cost between $300 and $600 per year, with monthly options ranging from $25 to $50. Most providers also charge a service call fee—typically $50 to $150—each time a technician visits.

These costs are predictable and often significantly lower than out-of-pocket repair or replacement costs. For homeowners with older appliances or HVAC systems, a warranty can offer substantial savings, especially for high-cost repairs like furnace or AC unit replacements.

Choosing the Right Home Warranty Provider

To select a reliable home warranty provider, focus on the following:

  • Coverage Flexibility: Does the company allow customisation to cover your specific systems and add-ons like swimming pools or septic tanks?
  • Service Reliability: Are certified technicians dispatched quickly? Does the provider have 24/7 customer service?
  • Transparency: Does the contract clearly state what’s covered, the claim process, and exclusions?

Key Questions to Ask Before You Sign:

  1. What are the average monthly and annual costs for plans?
  2. How much is the service call (trade fee) per claim?
  3. Are there any exclusions or waiting periods before coverage begins?
  4. Does the plan cover pre-existing issues or only new breakdowns?
  5. Can I add optional features like water line insurance or pool coverage?
  6. How does the claim and repair process work?
  7. What do verified customer reviews say about support and response time?
  8. Are there coverage caps on individual systems or appliances?
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Home Warranty
Do I need a home warranty if I have homeowners insurance?
Yes. Home warranties cover system failures due to regular use, which is not included in insurance.
Are there home warranties that cover pools or septic systems?
Yes, these are typically offered as optional add-ons.
How do I file a claim?
You submit a request via phone or online. A technician is then dispatched, and you pay only the set service fee.
Is a home warranty worth it for rental properties?
Absolutely. It helps landlords manage costs and avoid emergency repair stress.
What should I look for in the fine print?
Review exclusions, service limits, and maintenance requirements. Make sure there are no surprises.
Back To Top